India Opens Citizenship Door to Religious Minorities of Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh
POLITICS /
K.
Venkateshwar Rao
17 DECEMBER 2019
17 DECEMBER 2019
Despite protests by
Congress-led opposition parties and agitation by people of northeastern states
of India, like Assam and Arunachal Pradesh, the Indian Parliament passed its
Citizenship Amendment Bill (CAB) on the night of December 11. The Citizenship
(Amendment) Bill will grant citizenship to the non-Muslims – Hindus, Sikhs,
Christians, Buddhists, Jains, and Parsis – from Afghanistan, Pakistan and
Bangladesh on the plea that they fled their parent countries due to religious
persecution and arrived in India before December 31, 2014.
Before the Citizenship
Amendment Bill (CAB), these immigrants were labeled as illegal migrants. The
CAB paves the way for Indian citizenship to lakhs of immigrants, and people who
do not belong to the said communities would not be eligible for Indian
citizenship. Earlier, the duration of the immigrants’ residency was 11 years;
CAB had reduced it to five years. Opponents of the bill say faith cannot be
made a condition of citizenship as it violates the secular principles enshrined
in the constitution. The constitution prohibits religious discrimination and
guarantees all persons equality before the law.
The opposition parties
termed it as anti-Muslim and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government’s Hindutava agenda to
consolidate Hindu votes. They said the purpose of the bill is to tell the
Muslims, ‘you are not equal human beings with equal rights’. Congress interim
president Sonia Gandhi termed December 11 as a “dark day” in the constitutional
history of India and a “victory of narrow-minded and bigoted forces” over the
country’s pluralism. But Home Minister of India, Amit Shah, denied the charges.
He said the CAB is not meant to snatch anyone’s Indian citizenship;
it will provide citizenship to religious minorities who are being
persecuted in Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh. Home Minister Amit Shah
said existing rules are open for Muslims of other countries to apply for Indian
citizenship. He added that 566 Muslims have been given citizenship. Shah also
attacked the Congress for doublespeak on the issue, saying that during its
rule, the Congress party had given Indian citizenship to 13,000 Hindus and
Sikhs from Pakistan ignoring other communities.
According to political
observers, people in Assam and the other North-Eastern states fear that the CAB
will lead to lakhs of Hindus from Bangladesh flooding indigenous communities,
threatening their language, culture, and tradition and aggravating employment
situation in these states. People in Assam along with the other North-Eastern
states have their sentiments linked to their culture, language, and heritage.
Protestors are furious that Assam already bore the brunt of immigrants from
1951 to 1971; it is unfair to impose more immigrants on the state. The protestors
lamented that CAB is an attempt to legalize the 17 lakh Hindus and indigenous
tribes who were left out of the National Registry of Citizens prepared under
the guidance of the Supreme Court of India. Protesters now believe that the CAB
will make NRC redundant and bestow citizenship on illegal immigrants.
Why
Are States Opposing CAB?
The northeastern will
undoubtedly be the top electoral issue in the 2021 West Bengal and Assam
assembly elections. The BJP is hoping for a second term in Assam and wrests power
in West Bengal. Muslims constitute around 35 per cent of the population of
Assam and about 27-30 per cent in Bengal. The Citizenship Amendment Bill puzzle
makes it a Muslim versus non-Muslim debate. It will make the Bengal and Assam
elections a polarized political affair. The BJP, which is unpopular among
Muslims, hopes to gain from the counter-consolidation of Hindu votes as a
result of the consolidation of Muslim votes. The CAB will put BJP at an
advantageous position vis-à-vis other parties as, except Muslim, Hindu and
other minorities will vote for BJP.
The
ruling Bharatiya Janata Party accused Congress, and opposition parties of
spreading rumours and inciting people of Assam and northeastern states,
as the Citizenship Amendment Bill would not apply to tribal areas of
Assam, Mizoram, Meghalaya, and Tripura, as included in Sixth Schedule of the
Constitution and the area covered under the Inner Limit, notified under the
Bengal Eastern Frontier Regulation, 1873. This means that Nagaland, Arunachal
Pradesh, and Mizoram, the whole of Meghalaya and parts of Assam and Tripura
would stay out of the purview of the Citizenship (Amendment) Bill.
Defending the Bill, R
Jagannathan, editorial director of Swarajya magazine, wrote that “the exclusion of Muslims is due to
the obvious reality that the three countries Afghanistan, Pakistan and
Bangladesh are Islamists, either as stated in their constitutions or because of
the actions of militant Islamists, who target the minorities for conversion or
harassment.”
As the entire North
East continues to burn and opposition parties challenging the CAB in the
Supreme Court of India, it remains to be seen how long it will take for things
to settle down.
India Opens Citizenship Door to Religious Minorities of Pakistan, Afghanistan, and Bangladesh
Comments